When it comes to finding the best external hard drives, the choice mostly comes down to three questions: how much space you need, whether the drive has to travel with you, and how fast your transfers have to be. For most people, the WD 4TB My Passport is the pick I’d point to first — it balances a generous capacity, a compact shell, built-in 256-bit hardware encryption and backup software in one affordable package. If you need serious bulk storage for a desk setup, the WD 20TB Elements Desktop delivers the lowest cost per terabyte in this lineup, while the Seagate Portable 2TB is the simplest plug-and-play option for tight budgets. The main tradeoff in this category is speed versus price: every drive here is a spinning HDD, so none will match an SSD for speed, but all of them win handily on cost per gigabyte. Keep reading for the full breakdown of which model fits your setup.
Get the latest gadgets delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The WD My Passport line (2TB, 4TB, 5TB) separated itself from the plain Elements drives mainly through hardware encryption and included backup software — a real advantage if the drive leaves your desk.
- Capacity-per-dollar clearly favored the desktop models: the WD 20TB Elements and Seagate 16TB One Touch offered far more storage per dollar than any portable pick, but both require wall power and sacrifice portability.
- The 500GB ultra-slim generic drive was the only pick under 1TB, and it only makes sense as a niche purchase for console owners or light archives — its cost per gigabyte is the worst in the roundup.
- USB-C on the Seagate One Touch desktop drives (8TB and 16TB) future-proofs the connection, while most WD portable drives still ship with USB-A only — a real annoyance for modern laptop owners.
- Within the WD Elements portable family, the 4TB and 5TB models hit the sweet spot of capacity and price; the 2TB version is the same drive with half the storage, so I’d only pick it when the budget is fixed.
| external hard drife | Capacity | Interface | Form factor | Model |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Seagate Portable 2TB External | 2 TB | USB 3.0 | Portable | STGX2000400 |
| WD 20TB Elements Desktop Exter | 20TB | USB 3.0 | Desktop external hard drive | WDBWLG0200HBK-NESN |
| WD 4TB My Passport Portable Ex | 4TB | USB 3.1 / USB 3.0 | Portable | WDBPKJ0040BBK-WESN |
| Western Digital WD 5TB Element | 5 TB | USB 2.0 / USB 3.0; USB 3.2 Gen 1 | 2.5 inches | — |
| WD 4TB Elements Portable Exter | 4TB | USB 3.2 Gen 1 / USB 3.0 | Portable | WDBU6Y0040BBK-WESN |
| WD 6TB Elements Portable Exter | 6 TB | USB 3.2 Gen 1 / USB 3.0, up to 5Gbps | 2.5 inches | WDBHJS0060BBK-WESN |
| WD 2TB Elements Portable Exter | 2 TB | USB 3.2 Gen 1 / USB 3.0 | — | WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN |
| 500GB Portable External Hard D | 500 GB | USB 3.0 | 2.5 inches | — |
| WD 5TB My Passport Portable Ex | 5 TB | USB 3.1 / USB 3.0 | — | WDBPKJ0050BBK-WESN |
| Western Digital 8TB Elements D | 8 TB | USB 2.0 / USB 3.0 | 3.5 inches | — |
| Seagate 16TB One Touch Desktop | 16TB | — | Desktop | STNB16000400 |
| Seagate Portable 4TB External | 4TB | USB 3.0 | Portable | — |
| Seagate One Touch 8TB External | 8TB | — | — | STNB8000400 |
| Seagate Portable 1TB External | 1TB | USB 3.0 | — | — |
| WD My Passport 2TB Portable Ex | 2TB | USB 2.0/3.0 | 2.5 inches | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Seagate Portable 2TB External Hard Drive USB 3.0 (STGX2000400)
Simple plug-and-play backup is the Seagate Portable 2TB’s main appeal: connect its included USB 3.0 cable and drag files over without installing software. Its compact form suits laptop owners who want a drive they can carry between home and work, and compatibility with Windows, Mac, and PlayStation 4 gives it more flexibility than a desktop-only drive such as the WD 20TB Elements Desktop. The tradeoff is capacity: 2TB is a modest archive next to the 4TB and 5TB portable WD options in this lineup, so large photo or video collections may fill it sooner. The included cable is also only 18 inches, which can limit placement beside a desktop. I’d choose it for straightforward everyday backups, not for a growing media library.
Pros:- Plug-and-play setup requires no additional software
- Works with Windows, Mac, and PlayStation 4
- Compact design is easy to carry
- Included USB 3.0 cable supports simple drag-and-drop backups
Cons:- 2TB provides less room than the 4TB and 5TB portable alternatives in this lineup
- The included 18-inch cable limits convenient placement
- Usable capacity can be lower than the listed capacity
Best for: Laptop owners who want a basic, portable drive for documents, photos, and occasional console storage
Not ideal for: Videographers and households archiving large media libraries who need more than 2TB of room
- Capacity:2 TB
- Interface:USB 3.0
- Rotational speed:7200 RPM
- Read speed:120 MB/s
- Form factor:Portable
- Compatible devices:Laptop, PC, Mac, Sony PlayStation 4
- Installation:Plug and play
- Model:STGX2000400
Our verdict“Choose the Seagate for uncomplicated portable backups when ease of setup matters more than having the most space.”
WD 20TB Elements Desktop External Hard Drive (WDBWLG0200HBK-NESN)
For a buyer whose priority is keeping a large archive in one place, the 20TB capacity sets this desktop drive apart from every portable model in this batch. It can hold far more files than the WD 5TB Elements Portable, making it a better fit for sizable video collections, backups, or a household’s shared library. USB 3.0 transfers and Windows plug-and-play setup keep the basic workflow simple, but the desktop format is designed to stay put rather than travel with a laptop. Mac owners also need to reformat it before use, adding a setup step absent from the portable Seagate’s plug-and-play pitch. I’d rank it highly for stationary storage needs, while buyers who want a drive to toss in a bag should choose a portable option with less capacity.
Pros:- 20TB capacity accommodates much larger archives than the portable drives in this batch
- USB 3.0 supports fast data transfers
- Plug-and-play ready for Windows PCs
- Desktop format suits storage kept at a workstation
Cons:- Requires reformatting for macOS use
- Desktop design is less suited to travel than portable drives
- The supplied data does not specify a transfer speed beyond the USB 3.0 interface
Best for: Windows desktop users consolidating large video, photo, or computer backup archives on a stationary drive
Not ideal for: Mac users who want ready-to-use storage without reformatting, and travelers seeking pocketable backup space
- Capacity:20TB
- Interface:USB 3.0
- Form factor:Desktop external hard drive
- Windows compatibility:Windows 10+; plug and play
- macOS compatibility:Reformatting required
- Model:WDBWLG0200HBK-NESN
Our verdict“Pick the WD Elements Desktop when a large, stationary archive matters more than portability or immediate Mac compatibility.”
WD 4TB My Passport Portable External Hard Drive (Black) – WDBPKJ0040BBK-WESN
The My Passport pairs 4TB of portable storage with password protection and 256-bit hardware encryption, giving it a security advantage over the simpler WD 4TB Elements Portable. Its bundled backup and device management software also adds ransomware defense, which may suit someone carrying work files or personal records between locations. Those extras make this a more feature-rich pick, but they tie some of its appeal to WD’s own software; the Elements is the plainer choice for buyers who only want to copy files. There’s also no USB-C cable included, despite support for USB 3.1 and USB 3.0, so check that your setup has a compatible cable. I’d choose this model when portable capacity and file security matter more than a minimalist workflow.
Pros:- 4TB capacity in a slim portable design
- Password protection and 256-bit hardware encryption add file security
- Backup and device management software includes ransomware defense
- Three-year limited warranty
Cons:- No USB-C cable is included
- Backup software is proprietary to WD
- Security and software features add complexity for buyers who only need basic file storage
Best for: Mobile professionals and students who carry sensitive documents alongside a large personal file collection
Not ideal for: Buyers who want the simplest possible drive workflow or need an included USB-C cable
- Capacity:4TB
- Color:Black
- Interface:USB 3.1 / USB 3.0
- Security:Password protection, hardware encryption, ransomware defense
- Warranty:3-year limited
- Form factor:Portable
- Model:WDBPKJ0040BBK-WESN
Our verdict“Choose the My Passport if you want portable 4TB storage with built-in security features and are comfortable using WD software.”
Western Digital WD 5TB Elements Portable External Hard Drive
With 5TB in a compact portable enclosure, this Elements model offers the most space among the portable drives in the batch, edging the 4TB Seagate and WD options when a large library needs to travel. Its USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection is backward compatible with USB 3.0 and USB 2.0 devices, which helps when connecting to older computers or consoles. The listing also describes plug-and-play use with Windows and Mac, while noting that Mac reformatting is required out of the box; I’d plan for that setup step before relying on it. At a stated read speed of 50 MB/s, it prioritizes capacity over fast transfers, and the WD 4TB My Passport is a better match for buyers who value encryption and backup software. This one favors space and simplicity.
Pros:- 5TB capacity in a compact portable design
- USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection works with USB 3.0 and USB 2.0 devices
- Compatible with PC, Mac, and listed game consoles
- Suitable for backing up photos, videos, and other files on the go
Cons:- Stated 50 MB/s read speed is slower than buyers may want for frequent large transfers
- Mac reformatting is required for use out of the box
- Does not list the security features included with the WD My Passport
Best for: Traveling photographers and families who need a large portable archive for photos, videos, and console files
Not ideal for: Users who frequently move very large files and need faster transfers, or Mac owners seeking no-setup use
- Capacity:5 TB
- Interface:USB 2.0 / USB 3.0; USB 3.2 Gen 1
- Data transfer rate:5 Gbps (USB 3.2 Gen 1)
- Read speed:50 MB/s
- Form factor:2.5 inches
- Compatible devices:Desktop, laptop, tablet
- Compatible platforms:PC, Mac, Xbox 360, PlayStation 4
- Color:Black
Our verdict“Pick this Elements drive when carrying 5TB matters more than transfer speed or built-in file security.”
WD 4TB Elements Portable External Hard Drive, USB 3.2 Gen 1/USB 3.0, for PC & Mac (WDBU6Y0040BBK-WESN)
The WD 4TB Elements keeps the proposition straightforward: a compact drive with room for a substantial file library and USB 3.2 Gen 1 connectivity. It offers the same listed capacity as the WD 4TB My Passport, but skips that model’s password protection, hardware encryption, and ransomware defense. That makes the Elements a better fit for routine backups when a plain storage drive is enough, while the My Passport is more compelling for sensitive files. Compared with the WD 5TB Elements, this model gives up 1TB but remains a practical portable option for photos, music, and documents. The listing notes that a USB cable may not always be included, and macOS may require reformatting, so buyers should check both before counting on immediate use.
Pros:- 4TB capacity in a small, lightweight enclosure
- USB 3.2 Gen 1 / USB 3.0 connectivity
- Supports Windows PC and Mac
- Straightforward option for backing up photos, music, and documents
Cons:- USB cable may not be included with every purchase
- Reformatting may be required for macOS
- Lacks the My Passport’s listed encryption and backup software features
Best for: PC and Mac users who want portable 4TB storage for everyday backups without paying for extra security software
Not ideal for: People storing sensitive files who want hardware encryption, or buyers who need a guaranteed included cable
- Capacity:4TB
- Interface:USB 3.2 Gen 1 / USB 3.0
- Transfer speed:5Gbps
- Compatibility:Windows PC and Mac
- Form factor:Portable
- Model:WDBU6Y0040BBK-WESN
Our verdict“Choose the WD 4TB Elements for portable everyday storage if you can do without the My Passport’s security features.”
WD 6TB Elements Portable External Hard Drive, USB 3.2 Gen 1/USB 3.0, for PC & Mac (WDBHJS0060BBK-WESN)
The 6TB capacity in a 2.5-inch portable drive gives this WD Elements a rare advantage for people who need a large backup they can carry. It holds more than the WD 2TB Elements Portable while keeping the same basic plug-and-play approach, so it suits photo, video, and document archives that outgrow smaller drives. Its USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection supports transfers up to 5Gbps, though that interface figure does not make the mechanical drive as responsive as an SSD. The tradeoff is a plastic enclosure and HDD transfer performance that can feel slow when moving large batches. Choose it when portable capacity matters more than speed or rugged construction; skip it if you need frequent fast editing directly from the drive.
Pros:- Large 6TB capacity in a compact 2.5-inch portable form
- USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection supports up to 5Gbps
- Plug-and-play use with Windows PCs and Macs
- Useful for carrying substantial photo and video backups
Cons:- Mechanical HDD speeds lag behind solid-state drives
- Plastic enclosure offers less reassuring protection than a rugged design
Best for: Photographers and video creators who need to carry a large archive or backup without bringing a desktop drive
Not ideal for: People editing large projects directly from external storage or prioritizing a tougher enclosure and SSD-like response
- Capacity:6 TB
- Interface:USB 3.2 Gen 1 / USB 3.0, up to 5Gbps
- Form factor:2.5 inches
- Compatible devices:Desktop, laptop, tablet
- Enclosure material:Plastic
- Color:Black
- Model:WDBHJS0060BBK-WESN
Our verdict“Pick this WD Elements when you want unusually high capacity in a portable HDD and can accept slower transfers.”
WD 2TB Elements Portable External Hard Drive (WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN)
For routine backups and a portable file library, the 2TB WD Elements keeps things simple: connect it, then store photos, documents, and media without a dedicated setup process. It shares the lineup’s USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection with the 6TB WD Elements, but its smaller capacity makes more sense for everyday files than for a sprawling video archive. The compact, lightweight design is easy to move between a home computer and a laptop. Mac owners should note that the supplied format may need to be changed for their setup, and this listing provides only 2TB, regardless of the larger capacities available in the product family. It’s a practical basic drive, though buyers with growing archives may prefer the 5TB WD My Passport or 6TB Elements.
Pros:- Compact and lightweight for moving between computers
- Plug-and-play setup for straightforward PC use
- USB 3.2 Gen 1 connection supports up to 5Gbps
- Works with Windows PCs and Macs
Cons:- May require reformatting for Mac use
- 2TB capacity can fill quickly with large media collections
Best for: Students and home users backing up documents, photos, and a moderate media collection across Windows computers
Not ideal for: Mac users who want to use the drive without reformatting, or creators with large video archives
- Capacity:2 TB
- Interface:USB 3.2 Gen 1 / USB 3.0
- Transfer rate:Up to 5Gbps
- Compatibility:Windows PC and Mac
- Setup:Plug and play
- Model:WDBU6Y0020BBK-WESN
Our verdict“Choose the 2TB Elements for uncomplicated everyday backups, but move up to a larger model if your archive is expanding.”
500GB Portable External Hard Drive, USB 3.0 Ultra Slim HDD for PC, Mac, Laptop, PS4, Xbox
This 500GB drive weighs 0.35 pounds and is slim enough to pack alongside a laptop or console, making portability its clearest strength. Its listed read speed of up to 133MB/s is suitable for file storage and older-console game libraries, while the WD 2TB Elements offers four times the capacity for buyers with bigger collections. The broad compatibility list includes PC, Mac, PS4, PS5, and Xbox, but current-generation console games have a limitation: the drive can store them, yet they must be copied to the console’s internal SSD to play. Mac use may also call for reformatting to ExFAT. With only 500GB, this is a small-capacity companion drive, not a long-term home for a large media or game archive.
Pros:- Very light at 0.35 pounds
- Slim 2.5-inch form factor is easy to carry
- Listed read speed reaches up to 133MB/s
- Compatibility includes computers and several console generations
Cons:- 500GB capacity limits large game and media libraries
- Current-generation console games must be copied to internal storage to play
- Mac use may require reformatting to ExFAT
Best for: Traveling laptop owners or PS4 and Xbox players who need a lightweight drive for files and compatible game storage
Not ideal for: People building a large game library or expecting to play current-generation PS5 or Xbox Series X|S games directly from the drive
- Capacity:500 GB
- Interface:USB 3.0
- Form factor:2.5 inches
- Rotational speed:5400 rpm
- Read speed:Up to 133 MB/s
- Write speed:Up to 103 MB/s
- Weight:0.35 lbs
- Compatible devices:PC, Mac, laptop, PS4, PS5, Xbox One, Xbox 360
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“Choose this compact drive for portable file storage or compatible older-console libraries, not as a large or current-generation game drive.”
WD 5TB My Passport Portable External Hard Drive, Black (WDBPKJ0050BBK-WESN)
The 5TB WD My Passport pairs roomy portable storage with password protection and 256-bit hardware encryption, giving sensitive work files a layer of protection beyond what the basic WD Elements models list. It also includes device management software with ransomware defense, which may appeal to people managing recurring backups. Compared with the 6TB WD Elements, it gives up a terabyte but adds security features and a 3-year limited warranty. Those extras bring some setup: software functions may need configuration, and full functionality may require a subscription. The product data does not mention cloud storage or a USB-C cable, so check your connection needs before choosing it. This makes the most sense for carrying private files; buyers who only want straightforward bulk storage may find the Elements range simpler.
Pros:- 5TB capacity in a slim portable drive
- Password protection and 256-bit hardware encryption
- Device management software includes ransomware defense
- Backed by a 3-year limited warranty
Cons:- Software features may require setup and a subscription for full functionality
- USB-C cable and cloud storage are not specified
Best for: Consultants and professionals who carry confidential files and want portable capacity with password protection and hardware encryption
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking the simplest plug-and-play bulk storage or a specified USB-C cable and cloud backup service
- Capacity:5 TB
- Interface:USB 3.1 / USB 3.0
- Security:Password protection and 256-bit hardware encryption
- Software:Device management software with ransomware defense
- Warranty:3-year limited
- Color:Black
- Model:WDBPKJ0050BBK-WESN
Our verdict“Pick the My Passport if security features matter more to you than the 6TB capacity of the basic WD Elements.”
Western Digital 8TB Elements Desktop External Hard Drive
With 8TB of storage, this WD Elements desktop drive suits a computer that needs a substantial always-at-hand backup target. Its 3.5-inch form and 2.1-pound weight make it far less convenient to carry than the 5TB WD My Passport, but the larger desktop footprint makes sense when the drive can stay beside a workstation. USB 3.0 and USB 2.0 support offer connection options for older and newer computers; the product is formatted for Windows 10, 8.1, and 7. The listing does not specify Mac support, so cross-platform buyers should check compatibility before relying on it. Choose this for stationary business or personal storage, while travelers and laptop users are better served by a portable model.
Pros:- 8TB capacity for large backups and file collections
- USB 3.0 and USB 2.0 connectivity
- Plug-and-play setup for supported Windows PCs
- Suitable for stationary personal or business storage
Cons:- 3.5-inch desktop form is less portable than the My Passport
- Compatibility may vary across hardware and operating systems
- Listed Windows formatting limits confidence for Mac users
Best for: Windows desktop owners who want a high-capacity drive to keep beside a workstation for personal or business backups
Not ideal for: Laptop users who need portable storage or Mac owners who need explicitly listed compatibility
- Capacity:8 TB
- Interface:USB 2.0 / USB 3.0
- Form factor:3.5 inches
- Weight:2.1 pounds
- Dimensions:9 × 8 × 3.5 inches
- Compatibility:Windows 10, Windows 8.1, Windows 7
- Use:Business and personal storage
Our verdict“Choose the 8TB Elements for a stationary Windows backup setup, and the portable My Passport if you need to carry storage with you.”
Seagate 16TB One Touch Desktop Hard Drive – USB-C (STNB16000400)
When a 16TB single drive is on the table, most other picks in this roundup start to look small, and that is exactly this model’s pitch. Compared with the WD 20TB Elements Desktop, it trades a little raw capacity for a cleaner setup: bus-powered USB-C means one cord and no wall brick, which is unusual at this capacity and keeps a desk tidy. The included Rescue Data Recovery Services adds peace of mind that budget portable drives like the Seagate Portable 4TB simply don’t offer. The catch is power draw: it needs a 15W USB port, so older laptops or underpowered hubs may fail to run it, and it’s a desktop-class drive with no portability ambitions.
Pros:- Massive 16TB capacity consolidates entire media libraries in one place
- Bus-powered USB-C means no wall adapter and a single-cable setup
- Rescue Data Recovery Services included for added data protection
- Two-year limited warranty covers the drive itself
Cons:- Requires a 15W USB power output from the host device
- Desktop form factor is not meant for travel or mobile use
Best for: Content creators and archivists who want a huge, single-volume backup without a power adapter cluttering the desk
Not ideal for: Owners of older laptops or low-power USB hubs that can’t deliver the required 15W output
- Capacity:16TB
- Model:STNB16000400
- Connectivity:USB-C
- Power:Bus-powered (15W USB)
- Form factor:Desktop
- Warranty:2-year limited with Rescue Data Recovery Services
Our verdict“This is the pick when one drive has to hold everything and your machine can supply the power it demands.”
Seagate Portable 4TB External Hard Drive
This drive earns its spot by doing the basics with zero friction: plug-and-play setup, an 18-inch USB 3.0 cable in the box, and drag-and-drop backup that works on both Windows and Mac with no extra software. Against the WD 4TB Elements Portable, the experience is very similar, and the choice comes down to price and preference rather than capability. Where it falls short of the Seagate One Touch 8TB is long-term headroom — 4TB fills up fast for anyone shooting video — and it lacks the Rescue Data Recovery Services coverage that Seagate bundles with its desktop One Touch models. It also shares the common quirk that usable capacity is slightly below 4TB after formatting.
Pros:- True portable design that travels easily in a bag
- Works with both Windows and Mac out of the box
- Drag-and-drop backup with no software installation
- Plug-and-play USB 3.0 with included 18-inch cable
Cons:- 4TB ceiling feels tight for large media libraries
- No data recovery service or bundled backup tools
Best for: Students and home users who want dependable extra storage for documents, photos, and a modest media library
Not ideal for: Video editors or heavy media collectors who will outgrow 4TB within a year or two
- Capacity:4TB
- Interface:USB 3.0
- Cable length:18 inches
- Compatibility:Windows and Mac
- Setup:Plug and play; no software required
- Form factor:Portable
Our verdict“A fuss-free, no-software portable drive that makes the most sense for buyers who value simplicity over premium features.”
Seagate One Touch 8TB External Hard Drive Desktop HDD (STNB8000400)
The 8TB One Touch sits in a sweet spot between the portable options and the monster 16TB One Touch Desktop: double the room of the Seagate Portable 4TB while keeping the same one-cord, bus-powered USB-C setup and the same Rescue Data Recovery Services coverage. That recovery service is a genuine differentiator against the WD 8TB Elements Desktop, which asks for a separate power connection and skips recovery coverage. The tradeoff is speed — this is spinning-platter HDD technology, so anyone regularly moving huge video files will feel the wait compared with an SSD, and there’s no bundled encryption or cloud software to speak of. For capacity-per-desk-space, though, it’s hard to argue with.
Pros:- 8TB capacity offers substantial headroom for growing libraries
- Bus-powered USB-C keeps the desk clear of wall adapters
- Includes Rescue Data Recovery Services and a 2-year warranty
- Compatible with most Windows and macOS systems
Cons:- HDD speeds lag well behind SSD alternatives for large transfers
- No bundled cloud storage or encryption software
Best for: Photographers and households consolidating large photo and video archives on a desk setup
Not ideal for: Buyers who need fast file transfers or built-in encryption for sensitive data
- Capacity:8TB
- Model:STNB8000400
- Connection:USB-C
- Power:Bus-powered (no wall outlet required)
- Compatibility:Windows, macOS
- Warranty:2-year limited
- Includes:Rescue Data Recovery Services
Our verdict“The sensible middle ground for buyers who want serious capacity with recovery coverage but don’t need 16TB.”
Seagate Portable 1TB External Hard Drive, USB 3.0, Black
For a first external drive, this 1TB model keeps things simple and cheap: plug-and-play USB 3.0, a compact 190-gram body, and a 120 MB/s read speed that’s respectable for a spinning drive at this price. It also stands out as one of the few picks here with explicit Xbox One compatibility, which makes it a natural companion for console owners facing full internal storage. Compared with the Seagate Portable 2TB, you’re halving capacity to save money up front — a fine tradeoff for documents and game saves, a poor one for anyone backing up a whole computer. Note the Mac reformatting requirement, and that 1TB disappears quickly if photos and videos pile up.
Pros:- Compact, lightweight 190g design travels anywhere
- Plug-and-play setup with no software required
- Confirmed compatibility with Xbox One in addition to Windows and Mac
- 120 MB/s read speed on a 7200 RPM drive for the price
Cons:- 1TB capacity is limiting for media-heavy users
- Mac users must reformat before use
- Formatted capacity is slightly below the stated 1TB
Best for: First-time buyers and Xbox One owners who need modest, affordable extra storage
Not ideal for: Anyone backing up a full PC or a growing photo library — 1TB fills up fast
- Capacity:1TB
- Interface:USB 3.0
- Read speed:120 MB/s
- Rotational speed:7200 RPM
- Compatible devices:Desktop, laptop, Microsoft Xbox One
- Dimensions:4.61 x 3.15 x 0.58 inches
- Weight:190 g
- Cable length:18 inches
Our verdict“A low-commitment entry point that makes the most sense for light storage needs and console expansion.”
WD My Passport 2TB Portable External Hard Drive, Black
This is the pick where data protection, not raw capacity, is the story. The My Passport bundles hardware encryption, password protection, and backup software with ransomware defense — a package none of the Seagate drives in this lineup match, including the larger WD 4TB My Passport sibling that carries the same feature set at higher cost. The 3-year warranty also outlasts the two-year coverage on the Seagate One Touch models. Against the no-frills WD 2TB Elements Portable, you’re paying a bit more for that security layer, and the tradeoffs are real: the backup software requires a download and installation, and account registration may be requested before everything unlocks. For anyone carrying client files or personal records, those hoops are worth jumping through.
Pros:- Hardware encryption and password protection guard sensitive data
- Backup software includes ransomware defense
- 3-year warranty exceeds the typical 2-year coverage in this lineup
- Slim 2.5-inch portable design fits in a pocket
Cons:- Backup software requires a separate download and installation
- Account registration may be needed to unlock full functionality
- 2TB capacity is modest for the price-focused buyer
Best for: Professionals and privacy-minded users carrying sensitive files who need encryption and ransomware protection
Not ideal for: Buyers who want zero software setup — the security features require download, installation, and possibly account registration
- Capacity:2TB
- Interface:USB 2.0/3.0
- Form factor:2.5 inches
- Encryption:Hardware encryption
- Security software:Backup with ransomware defense and password protection
- Compatible devices:Desktop, laptop, tablet
- Warranty:3-year limited
Our verdict“The clear choice when encrypted, ransomware-resistant portable storage matters more than maximum capacity.”
How We Picked
I ranked these drives by the factors that actually shape a purchase decision: capacity relative to price, transfer performance, portability, durability, and included software. Because every drive here uses a spinning disk, real-world speed differences came down to platter density and USB version rather than dramatic gaps — so capacity-per-dollar and physical design carried more weight in the ordering. Desktop drives were judged as desk-bound storage vaults, while portable drives were judged on size, bus power, and how well they survive life in a bag.
I also gave credit for features buyers tend to overlook until they need them: hardware encryption, bundled backup utilities, and connector type. The WD My Passport models climbed the ranking on encryption alone; the Seagate One Touch desktop drives earned their spot through USB-C and large platter counts. Generic-brand drives had to justify themselves on something other than price, which is why the 500GB ultra-slim pick sits near the bottom despite its low cost.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Best External Hard Drives
Before settling on a specific model, it helps to understand the bigger tradeoffs in the external hard drive market. The drives in this roundup look similar on the surface, but small differences in design and capacity strategy lead to very different long-term outcomes.Portable Versus Desktop: Match the Form Factor to Your Workflow
This is the single biggest fork in the road, and getting it wrong is the most common mistake buyers make. Portable drives draw power from the USB cable, so they work anywhere with a laptop — but their 2.5-inch platters cap out around 5TB to 6TB. Desktop drives use 3.5-inch mechanisms that reach 16TB to 20TB and often run cooler and last longer under constant use, yet they need their own wall adapter and weigh pounds, not ounces. A useful rule: if you’ll unplug the drive even once a month, buy portable; if it will live on your desk, buy desktop and get double the capacity for the same money. Many buyers overpay for a portable 5TB drive when a desktop 8TB unit sitting permanently next to their PC would serve them better.
HDD Versus SSD: Know What You’re Actually Buying
Every drive in this roundup is a traditional spinning hard drive, and that’s a deliberate fit for backup and bulk storage — but you should know the tradeoff going in. HDDs typically transfer large files at 100–150 MB/s, while even budget portable SSDs run several times faster with no moving parts. If you plan to edit video directly off the drive or load games onto it for a console or gaming PC, an SSD is the better tool despite the higher cost. Where HDDs win decisively is cost per terabyte, which is why they remain the default for backups, archives, and media libraries measured in terabytes. A sensible strategy many buyers land on: one SSD for active work, one large HDD like the 20TB Elements for the archive that SSD feeds into.
Capacity: Buy More Than You Think You Need
Storage needs grow faster than almost anyone predicts — game installs now regularly exceed 100GB, and a phone photo library can quietly balloon past a terabyte. The pattern across this roundup was clear: larger capacities within the same product family cost only slightly more per unit, so stepping up from 2TB to 4TB usually makes more sense than buying a second drive later. My practical floor for a primary backup drive is 4TB; 2TB only makes sense as a secondary or travel drive. Beyond 8TB, you’re in desktop territory, and that’s where the cost curve really flattens — the 16TB and 20TB picks exist precisely because the price per terabyte keeps dropping as capacity climbs. Resist the temptation to buy exactly what you need today.
Encryption and Backup Software: The Features People Skip and Later Regret
A portable drive that leaves your house contains your tax documents, photos, and passwords in plaintext unless it’s encrypted. This is the main reason I ranked the WD My Passport series above the near-identical Elements series: My Passport includes 256-bit AES hardware encryption plus scheduled backup software, while Elements ships bare. Hardware encryption also doesn’t slow the drive down the way software encryption can. Third-party backup tools can fill the gap, but most people never install them — bundled software that activates out of the box gets used. If you’re buying for business travel or a student laptop, treat encryption as a requirement, not a nice-to-have.
Connectors and Compatibility: Small Details, Real Frustrations
Most drives here use USB 3.0 / USB 3.2 Gen 1 with a USB-A plug, which works everywhere but increasingly requires an adapter on modern laptops that only have USB-C ports. The Seagate One Touch desktop drives stand out for native USB-C, which future-proofs your connection and often simplifies cable management. Also check whether the drive ships pre-formatted for Windows (NTFS) — Mac users will need to reformat or run utility software, and most drives in this lineup ship Windows-first. Console owners face their own quirk: both PlayStation and Xbox work with these drives, but formatting requirements differ, and neither console will run PS5 or Xbox Series games directly from an external HDD — they’re for archives and last-gen titles only.
Reliability, Warranty, and the Two-Drive Rule
Every spinning drive in this roundup comes from either Seagate or Western Digital, which is itself a reliability signal — both manufacturers have mature quality control and offer warranties ranging from one to three years depending on the line. Still, no hard drive is immortal, and the biggest mistake I see is treating any single external drive as the backup. The drives with higher platter densities can run warmer, so give desktop units ventilation room rather than stacking them in a drawer. The strategy that protects you regardless of which model you buy: follow the 3-2-1 rule — three copies of important data, two on different devices, one offsite. A cheap 2TB portable drive makes an excellent second copy even after you buy a big desktop unit.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a meaningful speed difference between the WD Elements and WD My Passport drives?
In day-to-day transfers, no — both lines use similar 2.5-inch spinning mechanisms and the same USB 3.x interface, so you’re looking at comparable real-world throughput in the 100–130 MB/s range. The differences are elsewhere: My Passport adds 256-bit hardware encryption and WD’s backup software, while Elements is the bare-bones, lower-cost sibling. My guidance is simple. If the drive will sit at home next to a desktop PC, Elements is the smarter buy. If it travels with you or holds sensitive files, the My Passport premium buys peace of mind that matters far more than a few megabytes per second ever will.
Should I buy one 20TB desktop drive or several smaller portable drives?
One 20TB unit wins on convenience and cost per terabyte, but several smaller drives win on resilience — a single failure only takes part of your data with it. For a pure media archive where you can re-rip or re-download content, one big desktop drive is efficient and simple. For irreplaceable files like family photos, spreading copies across two or three drives (ideally with one stored elsewhere) is safer than any single unit, no matter the brand. A hybrid approach works well for most people: a large desktop drive as the hub, plus a smaller portable like the 4TB My Passport as the traveling second copy.
Can I use these hard drives with a PS5 or Xbox Series console?
Yes for storage, with one big caveat. Both consoles accept external HDDs over USB 3.0 for storing games, saves, and media, and drives like the Seagate Portable or the 500GB ultra-slim work well for last-gen titles and archives. The caveat: neither the PS5 nor Xbox Series will launch current-generation games directly from a mechanical drive — the consoles simply require faster storage. You can store a modern game on the HDD and transfer it to the internal SSD when you want to play, which is still faster than re-downloading. If your main goal is playing current-gen titles off external storage, you need a dedicated SSD, not any drive in this lineup.
Do I need to reformat these drives for Mac or Linux?
For Macs, almost certainly yes — most of these drives ship formatted as NTFS for Windows, which macOS can read but not write to without third-party software. Reformatting to exFAT takes a few minutes in Disk Utility and makes the drive fully read-write on both Mac and Windows, which is why exFAT is my default recommendation for anyone working across platforms. Linux users will find exFAT support built into current distributions as well. The one thing reformatting costs you is the pre-installed Windows backup software, but you can copy that installer off the drive first or download it from the manufacturer’s site afterward.
Are the higher-capacity portable drives (5TB and 6TB) less reliable?
There’s a kernel of truth here worth understanding. To reach 5TB and 6TB in a 2.5-inch enclosure, manufacturers use SMR (shingled magnetic recording) and denser platters, which can slow write speeds during large sustained transfers — sometimes noticeably — though reliability itself remains solid under normal backup duty. The WD 5TB Elements and 6TB Elements are fine for scheduled backups and file archives, where write bursts are short. If you frequently move hundreds of gigabytes in one sitting, a desktop drive like the 8TB Elements Desktop will feel quicker and run cooler because of its larger 3.5-inch mechanism. Treat capacity in portable drives as a convenience, not a performance upgrade.
Conclusion
Mapping these fifteen drives to real buyers is simpler than the list suggests, because most of them are variations on a few proven platforms. For best overall, the WD 4TB My Passport wins on balance: enough capacity for a serious backup, hardware encryption, backup software, and true pocket portability in one package. The best value pick is the WD 5TB Elements Portable, which trades the software extras for more raw storage at a lower price — ideal when the drive never leaves home.
For best premium, the WD 20TB Elements Desktop is the heavyweight answer for media hoarders, video editors, and anyone building a NAS-adjacent archive; the Seagate 16TB One Touch with USB-C is the alternative if modern connectivity matters more than maximum capacity. Beginners should start with the Seagate Portable 2TB — it’s genuinely plug-and-play with no software decisions to make — while console owners and students on strict budgets can grab the 500GB ultra-slim drive as a niche pick. And if you want one drive to carry everywhere with a laptop, the WD 5TB My Passport pairs maximum portable capacity with the same encryption as its smaller sibling. Whatever you choose, remember that any of these drives is only as good as your backup routine: one copy is never a backup.
Halloween Picks
halloween
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
